Published Article Details

Active or passive investing? How to pick the right strategy for yourself

Posted by: Uma Shashikant on Feb 03, 2020, 06.30 AM

Is this a good time to buy equity? The answer must be a yes or no. Investing expertise is judged by the ability to provide guidance about the future; or better still, offer advice about buying or selling that results in a clear profit or protects from a steep loss.

Timing and selectivity are primary contributors to investment success. Timing is about moving in or out of an asset class, based on an understanding of the macro environment and market cycles. When an adviser asks you to “book profits”, they want you to move money from equity to cash, so that you are protected if there is a correction in equity. Timing is thus an asset allocation decision.

Selectivity is about what you will buy within an asset class. You can find smallcaps losing while bluechips perform; telecom losing while tech stocks win; HDFC Bank stock going up, while YES Bank goes down. What you hold within equity dictates how much money you make.

Expertise in timing and selectivity need knowledge, skill and attitude, acquired and honed over market cycles. There are others who will manage your money, proposing that they have these skills and you can pay to draw the benefits. What are your choices?

Consider a matrix with four choices: Passive timing and selectivity; Passive timing and active selectivity; Active timing and passive selectivity; Active timing and active selectivity.

All four choices are available to investors, with varying costs, risks, returns and performance history. You can choose to remain fully passive. There is tremendous merit in that choice. You understand timing is tricky; that forecasting the future is not easy. However, you understand the merits of asset allocation and diversification.

You choose a strategic asset allocation— say 40% of your wealth is in equity. You stick to this proportion, review annually and rebalance. Passive timing doesn’t worry about markets or cycles. For selectivity, you choose passive again. Buy the indices. You make a return that mirrors the market. You can buy a mix of large-, mid- and small-cap indices, using low cost ETFs. You do not take an active call on which sector, which stock, and which fund. You are content with the market the market index that holds a representative set of stocks. You know that someone is making more money than you, but you don’t want to lose money trying to chase that rainbow.

This approach should be perfect for people who do not have the time, energy and interest in investments, but still want their money to earn a decent return. There is no drama here —just immense wisdom that average returns are the best case returns and low level of investment activity is good.

The problem is no one will “sell” this strategy to you. No one who earns their living by managing other people’s money can make any money out of this strategy. Portfolio managers, fund managers, investment advisers and distributors will not push for this simple approach. Why so?

The active investment management industry is built on the premise that above average return can be earned by someone who professionally manages timing and selectivity. The mutual fund industry showcases how returns on its products are better that of the index.

Beating the index and earning a fee for doing so is the business of active fund managers.

Investment managers primarily focus on selectivity. They modify portfolios to underweight sectors that aren’t doing well; they choose stocks they expect to perform, dropping those that don’t. They don’t hold the same index stocks, in the same proportions, but actively manage what they hold. They hope to do better than the index in the process.

Do they deliver results? Yes. Every year, the league tables features funds that have beaten the index; and funds that have underperformed the index. But the list of funds that win is not a fixed set of names. A different fund wins each year. Typically, investors chase that fund, after the act, in the hope of riding a winner.

On an average, however, if one bunches up all the funds, the good and bad performers cancel out one another, and we are left with index returns. That does not mean active fund management is wasteful—it just opens up the avenue for another level of work: fund selectivity.

If you choose passive timing and active selection, you can manage your 40% in equity by selecting a bunch of funds or portfolios or stocks to deliver returns. There is a risk but there is also a reward if you selected right. You can lean on advisers to select funds for you. Many distributors earn a fee for selecting funds, leaving you to manage the asset allocation and timing. Since they earn commissions from funds for selling, this activity has come under criticism.

What if you want active timing and passive selection? This is the job of the adviser. The professionals who know your needs, goals, and preferences and know about market cycles and macroeconomics. They will manage your asset allocation and protect your money; and they will implement the strategy using low cost index funds. We don’t have this useful category – no one pays them, and no one showcases the value this holds for the investor.

If you choose active timing and active selection, there is general chaos in that space. Many funds have products that offer both timing and selectivity. Fee-only advisers do it too, but we don’t pay them enough. A performance linked fee for the assets under advice is a reform that has sadly not happened.

Make your choice with the matrix we discussed. If your time and energy is devoted to earning money, choose passive; if you have an adviser you can trust, lean on them for fund selection. If you want to time the market and select what you believe are funds and stocks that will win, go ahead, it is your money! Just be sure you know what you are doing and who is accountable for the outcomes.

Online Courses

Other Financial products
Basic Level
BANKING AND SAVING PRODUCTS

Banking is a highly respectable career choice in India today. It is a growing sector which translates into

Other Financial products
Basic Level
DEPOSITS AND BONDS

The bond market is considered to be one of the safer avenues for investment, providing reliable and consist

Other Financial products
Advance Level
ALTERNATE ASSETS - COMMODITIES AS AN ASSET CLASS

Understand commodities as alternate assets for investing and their different types through our course.

Other Financial products
Basic Level
PERSONAL LOAN AND BUSINESS LOAN

Learn the working behind the process of issuing unsecured business and personal loans from our basic course

Other Financial products
Advance Level
BILL DISCOUNTING AND SUPPLY CHAIN FINANCING

Learn what bill discounting and supply chain financing is and its different features with our online course

Other Financial products
Intermediate Level
INTEREST MARGIN AND LENDING PROCESS

Learn how lenders make pricing and margin decisions during the corporate lending process through our course

Other Financial products
Advance Level
COMMODITIES TRADING

Learn the basics of commodity trading along with how commodity markets function via our beginner's course.<

Other Financial products
Basic Level
MORTGAGE FINANCE

Understand the need for mortgage finance along with the need, EMIs, pricing factors and repayment options.

Other Financial products
Intermediate Level
MATHEMATICS OF LENDING

Understand the concept of impaired loans and the mathematics behind lending through this online course.

Other Financial products
Advance Level
PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT SERVICES - 1

Learn about the structure, features, operational aspects and positioning of the products on the PMS platfor

Other Financial products
Advance Level
PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT SERVICES - 2

Learn how to construct individual portfolios and analyse risk and performance to meet investment objectives

Other Financial products
Intermediate Level
LEASE FINANCE AND FUNDING

Understand the benefits of leasing assets and different types of lease finance options through our online c

Other Financial products
Intermediate Level
LOAN AGAINST SECURITIES AND INSURANCE

The course guides you to understand its types, eligibility, margins and pricing on loanagainst securities a

Capital Markets
Basic Level
DEBT INSTRUMENTS - BASICS

Get a complete understanding of debt instruments in India. This course is ideal for professionals who want

Capital Markets
Basic Level
EQUITY MARKETS BASICS

More people in India are investing in equities and shares creating a need for more skilled equity managers

Capital Markets
Advance Level
EQUITY LINKED STRUCTURED PRODUCTS

Structured products are used to introduce tailor-made investment options in the world of finance. Our cours

Capital Markets
Basic Level
BANKING AND CAPITAL MARKETS

Get the training you need to work in the Banking and Capital Markets industry through this intensive course

Capital Markets
Basic Level
SECURITIES AND OPERATIONS PREPARATORY

This NISM preparatory training is designed to help students whowant to take the securities and operation ex

Capital Markets
Advance Level
DEBT INDICATORS

What factors affect the debt market? Learn all about debt market indicators to understand the world o

Capital Markets
Advance Level
DEBT MARKET ANALYTICS

Need help to understand the bond market? This bond valuation course simplifies debt bonds, bond yield

Capital Markets
Intermediate Level
CREDIT RATING

Poor credit ratings indicate risky investment opportunities. Learn about the concept of credit rating, its

Capital Markets
Advance Level
EQUITY VALUATION PRINICIPLES

Learn the different principles of equity valuation along with their real world applications.

Capital Markets
Intermediate Level
EQUITY MARKET INDICATORS

Reinforce your stock market basics by learning about equity market indicators through our online course.

Capital Markets
Advance Level
DEBT MARKETS LEVEL - 2

Understand the structure of debt capital markets and the structure of its primary and secondary markets.

Capital Markets
Advance Level
EQUITY MARKETS -II

Learn advanced methods of fundamental and technical analyses of financial statements in capital markets.

Mutual Funds
Intermediate Level
TAXATION ASPECTS FOR MUTUAL FUNDS

People in India are becoming increasingly savvy about the investment options available to them. Mutual Fund

Mutual Funds
Basic Level
MUTUAL FUND PRODUCT PRIMER

People in India are increasingly knowledgeable about the investment options available to them. Mutual Funds

Mutual Funds
Intermediate Level
MUTUAL FUND FACTSHEETS

Become a mutual fund investment advisor. This course will teach you the basics of mutual fund investment th

Mutual Funds
Basic Level
PREPARATORY COURSE FOR NISM MFD EXAM

This NISM modules preparation training is designed to help students who want to take the NISM examinations

Mutual Funds
Basic Level
MUTUAL FUND PROCESS PRIMER

Acquire the ability to provide complete financial solutions to investors using mutual funds through underst

Mutual Funds
Advance Level
PERFORMANCE EVALUATION OF EQUITY FUNDS

Learn to evaluate a portfolio thoroughly through our advanced level course on portfolio evaluation!

Mutual Funds
Intermediate Level
EQUITY FUNDS - PRODUCTS AND POSITIONING

Learn about the different types of equity funds and their positioning through ourintermediate level course.

Mutual Funds
Intermediate Level
DEBT FUNDS - PRODUCTS AND POSITIONING

Learn about the types of debt funds and their positioning through our intermediate level online course.

Mutual Funds
Intermediate Level
MUTUAL FUND PRODUCT POSITIONING

Learn how to choose and understand mutual funds products with our online course on mutual fund positioning.

Mutual Funds
Advance Level
DEBT FUNDS - RISK, RETURNS AND PERFORMANCE

Learn to market debt funds and how to calculate their risks and returns through our advance level course.

Mutual Funds
Advance Level
FUND SELECTION AND SUITABILITY

Learn to choose the right category mutual funds based on your clients' risk profile and financial needs.

Mutual Funds
Intermediate Level
LIQUID FUNDS AND TREASURY MANAGEMENT

Learn how to invest in liquid funds for treasury management through our advanced online course. Enrol now!<

Stock Broking
Intermediate Level
DERIVATIVE TRADING-2

Master the basics of option trading strategies and learn how to balance profits, risks and returns us

Stock Broking
Intermediate Level
EQUITY TRADING - 2

Delve into the nuances of equity trading strategies. Hone your skills to gain maximum rewards through this

Stock Broking
Basic Level
TRADING ACCOUNT - COMPLIANCE

Understand the consumer redressal procedures used by broking houses, their clearance and settlement process

Stock Broking
Basic Level
TRADING ACCOUNT - LEVELS - BASIC CONCEPTS

Get started with the basics! Learn how trading and DEMAT accounts are different along with their opening an

Stock Broking
Basic Level
DERIVATIVE TRADING

Get the tools and knowledge you need to understand derivative products. Learn about the pricing of differen

Stock Broking
Intermediate Level
MARGIN LENDING AND TRADING

Margin trading and lending is a high risk and return strategy. Learn how it works from our online course.

Stock Broking
Basic Level
DEMAT ACCOUNTS - PROCESS

Learn how to open and operate DEMAT accounts through our beginner level online course.

Stock Broking
Basic Level
EQUITY TRADING - 1

Learn the concepts of equity trading and trading strategies through our beginner level online course.

Stock Broking
Advance Level
DERIVATIVE STRATEGIES

Gain a thorough understanding of the best options trading strategies through our advanced online course.

Stock Broking
Intermediate Level
IPO AND MARGIN FUNDING

Understand the IPO funding process in India and their benefits to investors through our intermediate course

Stock Broking
Intermediate Level
LAS, IPO FUNDING & LEVERAGE

Learn about IPO, ESOP financing structures along with loans against securities through our online course.

Financial Planning
Advance Level
INVESTING ASPECTS FOR NRIS

Meet the fast-growing demand of an economy that is drawing foreign investors, particularly NRIs. This cours

Financial Planning
Basic Level
FINANCIAL PLANNING PRIMER

People are discovering how financial planning can help their money grow and prepare for a more secure futur

Financial Planning
Advance Level
MEASURING INVESTMENT RETURNS

Learn how to measure investment performance through analysing Returns on Investment (ROI) through this onli

Financial Planning
Advance Level
INVESTMENT RISK

Understand the nature of investment risk with our course on measuring investment risk and how to manage it.

Financial Planning
Advance Level
PRINCIPLES OF PORTFOLIO CONSTRUCTION

Learn to construct portfolios and the techniques used to allocate assets across classes and manage risk.

Financial Planning
Intermediate Level
FINANCIAL PLANNING AND MUTUAL FUNDS

Learn to invest based on investment goals and objectives through our Intermediate course on Mutual funds.

Macro Economics
Basic Level
MACRO ECONOMICS MADE EASY

This course gives you a thorough understanding of the key concepts in macro-economics and how to apply them

Macro Economics
Intermediate Level
UNDERSTANDING MONETARY POLICY

Monetary policies are designed to maintain price stability and ensure economic growth. Learn how monetary p

Macro Economics
Advance Level
EXCHANGE RATE AND EXTERNAL SECTOR

Understand how exchange rates fluctuate and the various factors that influence them through this online cou

Macro Economics
Advance Level
GOVERNMENT FINANCES AND FISCAL POLICY

Learn about the different sources of government revenue in economics and the implementation of fiscal polic

Macro Economics
Intermediate Level
MACRO ECONOMICS INDICATORS 1 - OUTPUT AND GROWTH

Learn how to measure economic growth and output through the macroeconomic indicators that influence it.

Macro Economics
Intermediate Level
MACRO ECONOMICS INDICATORS 2 - INFLATION

Learn about the macroeconomic indicators of inflation and their management through this online course.

Taxation
Intermediate Level
TAX ASPECTS OF FINANCIAL PRODUCTS

Financial advisors are in-demand and this course prepares you to be a well-informed financial advisor with

Taxation
Basic Level
PRINCIPLES OF PERSONAL TAXATION

As reforms in taxation take place, more and more professionals find they need help compiling their taxes. T

Taxation
Advance Level
TAX PLANNING FOR INDIVIDUALS

Learn the basic principles of tax planning for individuals and the various aspects that are involved in the

Taxation
Intermediate Level
PRINCIPLES OF BUSINESS TAXATION

Learn how to keep track of business expenses and income through our online course on business taxation.

Insurance
Basic Level
INSURANCE PRODUCTS

The insurance industry, like the rest of the financial world, is continually evolving.  Insurance prof

Insurance
Basic Level
BASIC PRINCIPLES OF INSURANCE CONTRACT

Insurance contracts differ from other contracts as they are based on the main principle of utmost good fait

Insurance
Intermediate Level
INSURANCE POSITIONING

Learn to conduct a needs analysis to determine the insurance products suitable for individuals at different

Insurance
Intermediate Level
INSURANCE UNDERWRITING

Learn how to assess risks faced by insurance companies while accepting insurance proposals. This course is

Insurance
Advance Level
IMPORTANCE OF PERSISTENCY IN INSURANCE

This course is designed to help you understand persistency in insurance and the measures taken to improve i

Mutual Funds
Intermediate Level
TAXATION ASPECTS FOR MUTUAL FUNDS

People in India are becoming increasingly savvy about the investment options available to them. Mutual Fund

Mutual Funds
Basic Level
MUTUAL FUND PRODUCT PRIMER

People in India are increasingly knowledgeable about the investment options available to them. Mutual Funds

Mutual Funds
Intermediate Level
MUTUAL FUND FACTSHEETS

Become a mutual fund investment advisor. This course will teach you the basics of mutual fund investment th

Mutual Funds
Basic Level
PREPARATORY COURSE FOR NISM MFD EXAM

This NISM modules preparation training is designed to help students who want to take the NISM examinations

Mutual Funds
Basic Level
MUTUAL FUND PROCESS PRIMER

Acquire the ability to provide complete financial solutions to investors using mutual funds through underst

Mutual Funds
Advance Level
PERFORMANCE EVALUATION OF EQUITY FUNDS

Learn to evaluate a portfolio thoroughly through our advanced level course on portfolio evaluation!

Mutual Funds
Intermediate Level
EQUITY FUNDS - PRODUCTS AND POSITIONING

Learn about the different types of equity funds and their positioning through ourintermediate level course.

Mutual Funds
Intermediate Level
DEBT FUNDS - PRODUCTS AND POSITIONING

Learn about the types of debt funds and their positioning through our intermediate level online course.

Mutual Funds
Intermediate Level
MUTUAL FUND PRODUCT POSITIONING

Learn how to choose and understand mutual funds products with our online course on mutual fund positioning.

Mutual Funds
Advance Level
DEBT FUNDS - RISK, RETURNS AND PERFORMANCE

Learn to market debt funds and how to calculate their risks and returns through our advance level course.

Mutual Funds
Advance Level
FUND SELECTION AND SUITABILITY

Learn to choose the right category mutual funds based on your clients' risk profile and financial needs.

Mutual Funds
Intermediate Level
LIQUID FUNDS AND TREASURY MANAGEMENT

Learn how to invest in liquid funds for treasury management through our advanced online course. Enrol now!<

Capital Markets
Basic Level
DEBT INSTRUMENTS - BASICS

Get a complete understanding of debt instruments in India. This course is ideal for professionals who want

Capital Markets
Basic Level
EQUITY MARKETS BASICS

More people in India are investing in equities and shares creating a need for more skilled equity managers

Capital Markets
Advance Level
EQUITY LINKED STRUCTURED PRODUCTS

Structured products are used to introduce tailor-made investment options in the world of finance. Our cours

Capital Markets
Basic Level
BANKING AND CAPITAL MARKETS

Get the training you need to work in the Banking and Capital Markets industry through this intensive course

Capital Markets
Basic Level
SECURITIES AND OPERATIONS PREPARATORY

This NISM preparatory training is designed to help students whowant to take the securities and operation ex

Capital Markets
Advance Level
DEBT INDICATORS

What factors affect the debt market? Learn all about debt market indicators to understand the world o

Capital Markets
Advance Level
DEBT MARKET ANALYTICS

Need help to understand the bond market? This bond valuation course simplifies debt bonds, bond yield

Capital Markets
Intermediate Level
CREDIT RATING

Poor credit ratings indicate risky investment opportunities. Learn about the concept of credit rating, its

Capital Markets
Advance Level
EQUITY VALUATION PRINICIPLES

Learn the different principles of equity valuation along with their real world applications.

Capital Markets
Intermediate Level
EQUITY MARKET INDICATORS

Reinforce your stock market basics by learning about equity market indicators through our online course.

Capital Markets
Advance Level
DEBT MARKETS LEVEL - 2

Understand the structure of debt capital markets and the structure of its primary and secondary markets.

Capital Markets
Advance Level
EQUITY MARKETS -II

Learn advanced methods of fundamental and technical analyses of financial statements in capital markets.